Pros And Cons of Man Made Diamonds

Over the past decade and a half, man-made diamonds (also referred to as zero-mined, lab-created, lab-grown, or lab-farmed diamonds, among other names) have increasingly gained traction as an alternative to naturally occurring sapphires. Since they look almost the same while being produced more ethically, they are an attractive purchase option for many. But, like any product, they have their pros and cons. This article digs into the pros & cons of man made diamonds so that you can determine whether or not they are right for you. Be it affordability, sustainability, or longevity, knowing these factors is golden.

What Are Man Made Diamonds?

Synthetic diamonds, also called Lab Diamonds, are diamonds that are manufactured in a technology-based process in a controlled laboratory environment. They replicate the process that forms diamonds far below the earth but over a much shorter duration. Similar to natural diamonds, which are composed of pure carbon, man-made diamonds have identical visual and structural properties.

Think You’re A Diamond Pro?

Select

Select

Think you’re a Diamond Pro and can save almost 50%? Choose the diamond that you like better. Is it the J color for $2,450 or the G color for $4,820?

The most fundamental difference has to do with where they come from; natural diamonds are excavated from the earth, while lab-grown diamonds are created using either High-Pressure High-Temperature (HPHT) or Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD). Because of their chemical composition and physical properties, man-made diamonds shine, sparkle and have the same hardness as natural diamonds.

For a deeper comparison between man-made diamonds and another popular gemstone, check out our guide on moissanite vs lab-grown diamonds.

Man-made diamonds offer a sustainable and ethical alternative without sacrificing the visual appeal of natural diamonds.

How Are Man Made Diamonds Created?

There are two primary methods of producing synthetic diamonds also known as Man Made Diamonds, HPHT (High-Pressure High-Temperature) and CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition). Both processes imitate the conditions in which natural diamonds occur, just in a lab. Here is an explanation of what each method does:

Method of HPHT (High-Pressure High-Temperature)

HPHT replicates the high pressure and temperature found deep within the Earth’s mantle, which is where natural diamonds are formed over millions of years. In this method:

• It all starts with a little piece or seed of diamond, in a compartment of pure carbon.
• The chamber is subjected to massive pressures (up to 5 GPa) and temperatures over 1,500°C (2,732°F).
• In this state, the carbon melts and starts producing a diamond crystal surrounding the seed.
• As time passes, the crystal continues to grow larger until it becomes a completed diamond.

This procedure is commonly used to form both colourless and yellow diamonds, with colour resulting from minor variations in carbon composition.

Method of CVD (chemical vapor deposition)

CVD employs lower pressures, but is still a high-temperature process. The emphasis is on producing a diamond from a mixture of gas components, particularly carbon. The process involves:

• First, they place a diamond seed in the vacuum chamber and expose it to a gas mixture, typically methane and hydrogen.
• Inside, the chamber is warmed to some 800°C (1,472°F) and the gas decomposes—into carbon atoms.
• The carbon atoms get deposited on the diamond seed plane by plane, then, slowly grow into a crystal of diamond.
• The growth process continues until the diamond reaches the preferred size.

CVD diamonds are usually made with high quality, colorless diamonds and can be manufactured with more control over its size and characteristics.

Key Differences Between HPHT and CVD Methods

Both methods offer unique advantages and can create diamonds that are virtually indistinguishable from natural diamonds. The controlled environments allow for more precise customization, such as color and size, which can be more difficult to achieve with mined diamonds.

Pros of Man Made Diamonds

There are many different benefits of man-made diamonds that make them a great option for so many different buyers. Here are some of the main reasons that explain Grown Diamonds are gaining more popularity:

Ethical and Conflict-Free:

• No Conflict Area: Another big advantage of synthetic diamonds is that there are no ethical concerns with the production, unlike with mined diamonds (so-called blood diamonds) from conflict areas. Lab created diamonds come from labs where no human rights abuses or unethical labor practices are involved.
• Ethical Sourcing: Man-made diamonds offer peace of mind for the socially conscious buyer who is concerned with where their jewelry comes from. These diamonds are marketed as an ethical alternative to mined diamonds, which can be sold to consumers with confidence that they are truly conflict-free.

Lower Cost:

• Price: Artificial diamonds are generally 30-40% cheaper than natural diamonds of the same size and quality. Their price gap can be attributed to the cost-effectiveness of lab production, and the fact that mining and transport costs, that drive the price of some resources, are removed from the equation.
• Affordable: Lab-grown diamonds are a more economical option to get the same dazzle and twinkle of natural diamonds without skimping on quality, be it an engagement ring or other fine jewellery.

Environmentally Friendly:

Lower Environmental Effect: The conventional extraction of diamonds can have considerable ecological effects, like the destruction of habitats, water pollution, and deforestation. On the flip side, lab-grown diamonds aka man made diamonds take substantially less resources to create.

Carbon-Neutral: Diamonds produced in a lab are a fraction of the carbon footprint than mine diamonds. As such, man-made diamonds are an environmentally-friendly option for buyers looking to limit their environmental footprint.

Customization and Innovation:

• Different Colors and Sizes: Since man-made diamonds can be created, they can be more easily customizable. Diamonds which are made in lab can be customised with their colour and size that can be rare or costlier with natural diamond. You can create stones like colored diamonds; for example, pink or blue in a lab which is a little bit difficult to be done by nature and there is a place for a challenge using both natural and synthetic stones in the jewelry industry.
• New Design Possibilities: Lab-grown diamonds free you to try more adventurous jewelry trends or custom designs. From a colored diamond to that particular size for your piece, the sky is the limit almost.

Thus, these benefits are the reason why man made diamonds are the better option for people looking for inexpensive but fair and versatile alternatives to real diamonds.

Cons of Man Made Diamonds

There are plenty of alluring benefits that come along with lab-grown diamonds, yet the cons can outweigh them. Below are several cons that may ultimately inform your decision on whether or not lab-grown diamonds are right for you:

Perceived Value and Resale:

• Reduced Resale Price: A major drawback of synthetic diamonds is they usually are worth less when resold compared to natural diamonds. Both types of diamonds appear very similar at first glance however, lab-grown diamonds do not retain the same value as natural diamonds. When you go to sell your lab grown diamond in the future, you might not be able to sell it for what you paid for it.
• Lack of Uniqueness: Everything will be seen as this may impact your consumer journey if you refer to lack of uniqueness then some buyers believe lab-grown diamonds do not have the same uniqueness or specialness as natural diamonds that were created over millions of years. Such an impression could influence how people regard the entire worth of man-made diamonds against mined diamonds.

Limited Rarity Appeal:

• No Natural Rarity: Real diamonds can be attractive because of their scarcity and the geological forces that go into their making. Lab-grown diamonds are not rare because they can be synthesized in unlimited quantities and are therefore not physically and chemically identical.
• Investment concerns: Natural diamonds may be considered a long-term investment due to their inherent scarcity, but on the other hand man-made diamonds do not have much investment value. Because of the fact they lack rarity this do not appreciate for the future, which makes them of no interest for buyers looking for a long term asset.

Market Confusion:

• Confusion Among Consumers: While lab-grown diamonds have begun to gain traction, some confusion on the marketplace remains. When consumers find the two diamond types marketed together, a lot of them find it difficult to tell which is natural and which is man made. Because of this confusion, though, it may raise red flags on the transparency of the sellers, especially if they are online sellers or sellers with less or no credibility.
• Marketing Misleads: The diamond industry can blend lab-grown and real diamond marketing, causing buyers to be confused about their real purchase. Before you make one option over the other, it is wise to educate yourself on each option and their variations.

Traditions and Sentiment:

Preference for Natural Diamonds: Many still prefer natural diamonds due to any sense of tradition or sentimental value. The notion that a diamond has been created over millions of years appeals to the romance of it for some, particularly when it comes to milestones like engagements or weddings.

Emotional Connection: Some buyers have a sentimental attachment to mined diamonds because they represent a tangible, historical and natural origin. For marking an important life events they may feel a lab-grown diamond does not have this infinite bond.

Betwenn the Pros & Cons of Man Made Diamonds, However, for some jewelry shoppers, the cons may be a dealbreaker if they value rarity, tradition, or the ability to invest in their purchases.

Are Man Made Diamonds Right for You?

Whether or not man-made diamonds are right for you really boils down to where your values and priorities lie. Although lab diamonds have several great advantages, like being less expensive and ethically sourced, the natural diamond lovers might disagree because of its rarity and tradition. A guide to help you assess whether diamonds made by man are most appropriate for your needs:

Key Factors to Consider:

• Ethical Concerns: For some folks, ethical sourcing is a top priority, and this is another area where lab grown diamonds offer peace of mind, knowing they won’t be supporting a conflict zone or unfair labor practices. An man-made diamond is conflict-free, which makes them a better choice for those who appreciate socially responsible buying.
• Budget: Do you want an affordable option of a high-quality diamond? Lab diamonds cost 30–40% less than natural diamonds, so you can purchase a larger or higher-quality stone for the same budget. Man-made diamonds makes a perfect choice for those who have price sensitivity as their top priority.
• Environmental Impact: If you are trying to make a plan for sustainability and nature, man-made diamonds are more responsible to nature and produce a smaller carbon footprint and other negative impacts compared to traditional mining. They are an environmentally friendly choice for the eco-conscious shopper.
• Sentimental Preference: There are still people who opt for natural diamonds because of their ancient origins, and because they are natural and rare, with ties to tradition. If you are attracted to the notion of owning a diamond that has taken millions of years to form, a natural diamond may become more meaningful to you.
• Resale Value: If long-term value and the potential to resell is important to you, remember that lab-grown diamonds are often worth less than natural diamonds when it comes to resale. While they may seem to be a great affordable option in the first place, they do not always hold their value as natural diamonds do.

Explore Your Options:

Whether you love the ethical, affordable appeal of a lab diamond or you’re still coming to terms with what rarity means for you, there is a perfect diamond choice for you. Both natural and lab-created diamonds can be exciting to shop for, so take your time to explore what will work best for your needs.

Below you will find a variety of man-made and natural diamond retailers that we trust:

• Enjoy great value and design options, with carefully selected lab-grown diamonds on Blue Nile.
• Shop beautiful lab-created diamonds and engagement rings by James Allen, an industry leader in 360° view and high quality craftsmanship.

Once you understand the advantages and disadvantages of man made diamonds, you are now all set to make a decision that reflects who you are and what you stand for and most importantly your budget.

Conclusion: Weighing the Pros and Cons of Man Made Diamonds

Overall, man made diamonds have a number of benefits – they are ethically sourced, affordable and environmentally friendly. They are a stylish, sustainable option for buyers looking for an affordable yet high-quality diamond. Still, resale value, general market confusion, and limited rarity appeal could make some buyers lean in the diamond direction

In conclusion, the choice between natural and synthetic diamonds is entirely up to your preferences and values. Lab-grown diamonds are the best option if ethics and affordable diamonds are your main concern. However, if you value tradition, sentiment, or do not mind a longer investment, then natural diamonds may be the right option for you.

When it comes to the consideration of man-made vs. natural diamond, what is most significant to you? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below!

FAQs about Pros and Cons of Man Made Diamonds

Q. Do man-made diamonds look different from natural diamonds?

No; man-made diamonds are chemically identical to natural diamonds. They come with similar shine, luster, and strength, making it close to impossible to differentiate one from another without specialized tools.

Q. Are lab-grown diamonds a good investment?

Man-made diamonds are quite good value for money as a purchase price but they rarely retain value like a natural diamond. Natural diamonds have greater long-term investment potential, while lab-grown diamonds have a lower resale value.

Q. Are lab-grown diamonds cheaper?

Yes, lab-grown diamonds are typically 30-40% less expensive than natural diamonds of the same size and quality. This makes them a more budget-friendly option for buyers. For a more detailed breakdown of why lab-grown diamonds are more affordable, check out our post on Are Lab Grown Diamonds Cheaper?.

Q. Is it difficult to find man-made diamonds in various sizes and colors?

Actually, lab-grown diamonds can virtually be any size or color to suit your personal taste and preference, an advantage to further customizing the ring that a natural diamond does not, allowing you to get exactly what you want. They are found in different forms, dimensions, and even exotic colors.